My opinions on many things this life offers changes very frequently.. some call it flexibility some call it fickle-mindedness.. but that is what I am!!
Search This Blog
ICICI Prudential Life Insurance uses Service calls to churn ULIPs/ULPPs
Gold – Are you a bull or a bear?
FMPs - Alternate Investment to Bank Fixed Deposits
This time of the year, you see lot of FMPs hitting the market. Wondering what is FMP!
FMP stands for Fixed Maturity Plans offered by Mutual Funds in India. Mutual Fund houses collect money through an FMP scheme and lend that money to borrowers for a fixed maturity periods or buy commercial papers or bonds which matches with the scheme maturity date. The FMPs are debt instruments and they dont have any equity exposure at all. Also, the FMPs would invest in rated securities which gives additional comfort as far as the quality of credit instruments held by the FMP scheme.
It is being positioned as an alternative to bank fixed deposits by the fund houses. Yes, FMPs are an interesting alternative with highly tax efficient structure due to indexation benefits on Capital Gains. We will see how this beneficial from a tax perspective.
The process works like this.
What happens in a bank fixed deposit?
You invest Rs10000 and receive back Rs11000. The difference between the original investment and the maturity value is treated as interest income and taxed as "interest from other sources" in case of bank deposits.
What happens in a FMP?
Taking the same example above, the amount invested is considered as the cost of purchase of a financial asset, in this case, mutual fund units and the maturity amount is taken as the sale consideration. So, the difference between the purchase price and the sale consideration is treated as profit on this asset.
Whats the big deal about this?
When it is treated as interest, it gets added to one's taxable income and get taxed at the applicable income tax rates of the individual (in case of bank fixed deposits)
When it is treated as profit, then the Capital Gain provisions kick in for tax calculations. As you may be aware, Capital Gains have preferential tax treatment and the highest tax rate is 20% which is lower than the 30% tax rate for general income tax calculations. Also, you get indexation benefit from financial assets held more than 1 year. The beauty is if it is held across two different financial years, you get double indexation benefit. For example, you purchase a 390 days FMPs on 10th March 2013 and it will mature on 05th April 2014. So, in this case, you will get indexation benefit for 2 years, that is, for FY 2013-14 and 2014-15. This is called double indexation.
Can it replace the Bank Fixed Deposits completely?
Okay, then the moot question is can it completely replace the Bank Fixed Deposits in one's portfolio. The simple answer is NO.
The following are the reasons why you need to maintain a balance between bank fixed deposits and FMPs:
Liquidity: The liquidity provided by bank fixed deposits are unmatched currently by FMPs . FMPs are close ended instruments which are listed on the stock exchanges but the volumes are not very encouraging. For that matter, trading in debt instruments in India is still at a very nascent stage putting at little risk the liquidity of FMPs.
No up front disclosure of Interest rates: Secondly, there is no guaranteed interest rates by the Mutual Fund houses in respect of FMPs. Bank Fixed Deposits disclose the interest rates up front but in FMPs it can not be disclosed by Fund Houses due to SEBI restrictions on the same.
Opaqueness in FMP scheme holdings: It is not disclosed by the Fund House prior to your investment where and which instruments they would be subscribing to. As such, you have to go with the stated objectives in the Key Information Memorandum of the scheme. But having said that, I would not give too much weightage to this argument because even banks don't disclose where they invest or lend at the time of taking deposits from the investor.
Suitability of FMP:
Who should invest in FMPs?
1. People who are in the highest tax bracket as it provides tax efficiency
2. Investors who have adequate bank deposits to meet emergency situations and looking to diversify beyond bank deposits
So are you looking for tax efficient alternative to Bank Fixed Deposits? Look no further than FMPs.
Please feel free to write back to us (venkytuty@gmail.com) if you require any further information on FMPs or help in making investment in FMPs.
Power Finance Corporation - Tax Free Bonds 2012
Face Value
|
Rs1000 per Bond
|
Minimum Application
|
Rs 5000 or 5 Bonds
|
Interest Rate
|
7.69% for 10 years option
7.86% for 15 years option
|
Mode of Allotment
|
Dematerialised and Physical Form
|
Credit Rating
|
Crisil - AAA; ICRA – AAA
|
Listing
|
Bombay Stock Exchange
|
Issue Open
|
14th Dec 2012
|
Issue Closes
|
21st Dec2012
|
Shriram City Union Finance - NCD Issue - Invest
Shriram City Union Finance, a non-banking Finance Company (NBFC) from the Chennai headquartered Shriram Group of Companies is launching a secured Non-Convertible Debenture from 12 Sep 2012. Shriram City Union Finance plans to collect Rs250 crores with a green-shoe option of another Rs250 crores.
The NCD has a 3 year and 5 year option investment option. The coupon rate for the 3 year investment is 11.5% and the coupon rate for 5 years is 11.75%. Please note these rates are applicable only for investments less than Rs5 lakhs under the Reserved Resident Individual Category. The face value of every NCD is Rs1000 and investors can invest in multiples of Rs1000.
Shriram City Union Finance is an existing profit making company engaged in the business of lending for consumer durables, two-wheelers and small businesses. The business is concentrated in the four southern states and Maharashtra, which accounts for more than 65% of the branches. The objective of the issue is to use the proceeds to repay existing loans, expand business and other routine business purposes. The net interest margins made by Shriram City Union Finance are mouth-watering at more than 7%!
Credit Rating:
One of the important points to note in case of these long term debt instruments is how sound their business is. This is known through the credit rating assigned by the various credit rating agencies employed by the issuer for this purpose.
The NCD of Shriram City Union Finance has Crisil’s investment grade rating of AA-, which denotes "high degree of safety regarding timely financing of financial obligations".
Mode of Holding:
Please note, it is mandatory for all the applicants to apply for these NCDs only in the dematerialised form. That is, you need a Demat account to apply for this issue.
Investment Alternatives:
While making each and every investment it is very important to analyse what are the available alternatives. In this case, the available alternatives are bank deposits and already existing NCDs from Shriram and other companies like Tata Capital, which are listed on the Stock Exchanges.
Bank deposits currently don't offer similar returns for either 3 or 5 year deposits. The only advantage they would provide is deposit insurance guarantee for a aggregate sum of Rs1 lakh for every investor.
Looking at the other option of existing listed NCDs, there are few NCDs which are available at a little higher yield to maturity, like Tata Capital. But the biggest problem in India is the lack of liquidity in debt segment of stock exchanges. The average traded volumes are much lower in the region of Rs30 lakhs per day. You may get a slightly better yield if you are able to pick up existing NCD's from the stock exchanges, but for a layman this would be a tough ask.
Taxation:
All returns from NCDs are taxable under the "Income from Other Sources" head as per the Income Tax Act. Therefore, the effective yields on the NCDs would be less compared to the coupon rate what has been mentioned above, depending on the tax slab you are in. The issuer, Shriram City Union Finance, would not deduct tax at source (TDS) for the NCDs irrespective of the amount invested.
Investment Recommendation:
Considering the fact that the deposit rates are moving down and further expected to slide, I believe that this a good opportunity to lock a portion of your fixed income investments at an attractive interest rates. I would suggest that you may use this opportunity and apply for NCDs not exceeding 2% to 5% of your overall portfolio value. (For portfolio sizes which are bigger than Rs30 lakhs). For others, you may go up to Rs50,000.
As there are no put or call options in this issue, there is no threat of early redemption by the issuer.
Hope you find this information useful and please do let me know if you require any help in applying for this NCD.
Update on subscription status:
As of 14th Sept 2012, the issue has been subscribed 0.83 times, that is around Rs206crores out of the total issue size of Rs250 crores.
Retail subscription less than Rs5 Lakhs - 1.92 times
All other categories have minuscule subcriptions
Disclaimer:
Please note these are my personal views on this investment and I strongly urge you to check with your Personal Financial Planner before you decide on investing in this NCDs. The views expressed here are my personal views and no way related to my current, past or future employers. This post is not a solicitation to invest in Shriram City Union Finance NCDs.
Who is the real beneficiary of Physical Gold SIPs offered by Jewellery houses?
Sensing a big business opportunity is the Indian Jewellery community which is now vigorously marketing the systematic investment plan in physical gold. Almost all the jewellers in Chennai have launched schemes where people can invest a specified amount of money and the equivalent amount of gold would be credited to their account at the prevailing rate. The jewellers sweeten this deal by foregoing the traditional making charges and wastage. The jewellers market this scheme by informing the gullible investors that the price at which gold they bought is protected for future price escalations. Their basic assumption is that the "price of gold would continue to raise forever". One of the basic tenets of economics is that nothing can keep raising forever and what goes up has to come down sometime.
There are number of questions which crosses my mind:
1. Lack of regulations: Who regulates these jewellers with regard to these systematic investment plans? The answer is nobody regulates them and nobody independently certifies that the price at which the gold is alloted to investors are in alignment with the market price.
2. Credit worthiness of the jewellers: These systematic investment plans are long term products running for 12-18 months and exposes the investors to default risk. They have nothing else to fall back upon other than the empty guarantees of these jewellers.
3. Price risk: One of the biggest risks is what happens tomorrow if the price of the gold crashes to pre-2008 levels? In my opinion this is one of the biggest risks associated with these schemes. You may ask how it is different if I buy gold today at high prices and subsequently the price goes down? Good question, but the answer is the gold you buy today is a bird in hand compared to these schemes where you just pay the money to the jeweller and expect him to honour the committment after 24 months or so.
4. Lack of transperancy: Normally, for these type of transactions, the seller has to properly hedge their positions in the gold market. But we don't know if these are being properly done by the jewellers on a daily basis. Also, I am afraid they dont mark to market their losses if any and account it in their books of accounts. I think I am sounding too naive to expect our Indian Jewellers to do this prudent accounting. First of all, let them account all their sales!
5. Risk of over-trading in commodities/derivatives exchange: If we assume that the jewellers try to hedge their positions in the derivatives market, then there is a risk of over-trading in the derivatives market by the jewellers. We have seen many instances in the past when the traders have literally lost their shirt by excessively trading on the commodity derivatives market. Very recently, there were press reports of the promoters of KS Oils losing huge money by trading in the palm oil futures.
So, overall there are huge risks assumed by the people who go for this systematic investment plans with jewellers and it is better to avoid them altogether. If you want to buy gold, just buy it over the counter rather than joining a scheme like this.
Personal Finance and pilferage
Rising inflation and negative return on assets
The rising inflation makes me shudder what would happen to savings and the retirement corpus. Would fixed deposits and bonds help you in retaining the value of your savings? The answer is a clear no. We need to identify avenues where you can deploy your money and where the returns outpace the inflation? Are there any asset classes which can help you do that? Yes, the obvious answer emerged is to invest in equities and real estate from an individual perspective. The other option would be park a limited portion of the funds in Gold, as a store of value. Remember, Equities, real estate and Gold, as asset classes have their own inherent risks.
So how would these asset classes help in beating inflation? In case of equities, if the rising price levels are to continue, the sales and profits of the listed companies should also improve in that proportion and the share market should reward these companies in the form of capital appreciation. Historically that has been case. But the fact of the matter is finding high quality equity which would continue to grow and deliver for you. You always get a feeling that equities have been fairly priced and there is no room for further appreciation. You don’t know when to invest. Take the case of current global economic scenario. It is definitely not that encouraging. The in-famous SPIG (Spain, Portugal, Ireland and Greece) countries are facing default threat on their sovereign debt. If that happens there would be definitely another round of sell-off across asset classes in the world markets. When would that happen or would it not happen? Nobody has a clear idea about this. From past data and it has been seen that there is no better way than investing in a systematic manner. To put it simply, keep investing a fixed amount every month in equities either directly or through Mutual Funds. It would take care of the rising or falling trends in the market place and even out in the longer time horizon.
Looking at the Real estate, with rapid urbanization it would be worthwhile to invest in plots though it is very tedious and time consuming process. You have to identify a location and then keep looking for good properties. It also involves a high percentage of cash transactions (particularly for land transactions) which makes all the more difficult for the salaried class. But what I have seen is that real estate prices have held their own, at least to a limited extent, even in the worst of times. I am not talking about highly priced flats. So the best way forward is to start investing in equity in a Systematic manner either through Mutual Funds or buying high quality individual stocks. Real Estate should be the next best option, if you have the time, money and energy to scout for good properties. Add a flavor of gold (in the form ETF’s) to your portfolio and you are relatively well-placed to face the inflation.
Facebook!
Delay in getting PF statements
Provident Fund is one of the silent saving mechanisms for salaried class and each one of us would be eager to have an idea of how much is lying in my account, how much interest I have earned in the last year. This is particularly important if you have made voluntary contributions to the Provident Fund account in addition to your statutory contributions. I have tried couple of times with my employer to initiate the Voluntary contribution of PF, but somehow or the other the HR ensures that the deduction doesnt happen. We have a policy of opting for Voluntary PF only at the begining of the financial year, that is, in April every year.
Is this only with the Mumbai RPF Office or it is the same case with other Regional PF offices as well. People in the know please post your comments.
Due dates and relevant forms for tax filing
The due date for filing income tax returns is fast approaching for various kinds of assessess. The following are the various types of Income Tax Return Forms which needs to be used by assessees for filing their return of income for the Assessment Year 2008-09 (Financial year ending 31 March 2008).
ITR 1 - For Individuals having Income from Salary/ Pension/ family pension & Interest
ITR 2 - For Individuals and HUFs not having Income from Business or Profession
ITR 3 - For Individuals/HUFs being partners in firms and not carrying out business or profession under any proprietorship
ITR 4 - For individuals & HUFs having income from a proprietary business or profession
ITR 5 - For firms, AOPs and BOIs
The due dates for filing return of income is as givine below:
I Where the assessee is a Company - 31st October of the Assessment year.
II Where the assessee is a person other than a company :-
a) where accounts of the assessee are to be Audited or 2.a working partner of a firm whose accounts are required to be audited under the Income Tax Act or any other law - 31st October of the Assessment Year.
b) Where the return has to be filed under the one-by-six criteria - 31st October of the Assessment Year.
c) Any other assessee - 31st July of the Assessment Year
For the salaried employees the due date for filing return of income is 31 July 2008.
Chidambaram's budget gives a salary hike!!
This was more evident when I visited the Mega Mart retail showroom at Valasaravakkam yesterday to pick up some shirts. As usual with Mega Mart, there were good discounts on select brands like Arrow and Park Avenue. For Arrow shirts and trousers, they were offering a straight 40% discount and for Park Avenue they were offering 50% discounts when you buy two. I think these are real good bargains!!
I spent close to couple of hours and one thing which caught my attention was the constantly increasing crowd in Mega Mart. There was a good influx of crowd during the two hours I spent and when I finally left, the car parking was full, two-wheelers were asked to park in the road outside as 2 wheeler parking was also full. Mind it, this is not a peak season for buying clothes as there are no festivals coming in the near future. Inspite of that, people are visiting outlets like Mega Mart to buy clothes.
The other area where I think the tax savings would flow would be electronic consumables like computers. India has a very low peneteration on home PC's and I believe households would look at buying computers to help their kids sharpen their skills. Telecom would be another major beneficiary due to the higher disposable income.
Watch out http://www.ideas2wealth.blogspot.com/ for knowing how to prudently invest the additional money you have now!!
Free switches in Pension Funds - should use it more pro-actively!!
I guess, we all got an opportunity to exercise this option of switches during the recent market crash. The Nifty was cruising along above 6000 levels in January 2008 in-spite of global markets correcting in a big way. Like most of the investors, I was also feeling uncomfortable with the equity valuations, but did nothing other than speculating when the market would crash. I definitely believed that the valuations are stretched and anytime the market would fall. Knowing this, I did nothing to protect my pension plan accumulations. I just completely ignored the need for protecting my capital accumulated under the pension scheme.
What I should have done during Dec/Jan 2008 was to have moved from equity oriented "Maximiser" option in ICICI Prudential to a debt option. By doing this, I would have avoided a huge erosion in the NAV of my Pension accumulation. This is a good lesson and now I understand the need and importance of having "free switches" in these pension plans.
I need to find out the following in these pension plans:
1. Can partial switch-over of the accumulated units possible? I guess, it should be possible.
2. How the actual process of switch happens?
Though all companies claim free switches, practically insurance companies would have built a cost to the investor by having a entry load into the new scheme.
3. How many days does it take to carry out a free switch?
4. What modes can be used to carry over the switch? Phone, online facility or the time tested hard copy letters?
5. Is there anybody who has done these switches successfully in the past what has been their experience? Did they pre-empt the crash in 2008 and protected their retirement nest egg?
If anybody has more information on the above questions, please post it as your comment.
LIC launches Unit Linked Health Insurance plan
LIC is today lauching nationally the Unit Linked Health Insurance plan. I think it is the first time a health insurance plan is launched as a unit linked policy. The policy provides for Hospitalisation Cash benefit and Surgery Benefit. The administration and other charges are little high.
- LIC is planning to invest between 10% to 50% of the insurance premium in equity market.
- 30% of the first year premium would be taken as adminstration and other charges.
- 6% of the premium would be taken from the second year as administration charges.
Came across this blog with some information on this policy. Click here to view further details.
Current issue of Outlook Money
Click here to access Outlookmoney web edition after Dec 15 or any of the earlier editions. Read and enjoy!!!